Curated Golf Guide

Best Golf Courses in Shelter Island Heights

Discover the top-rated golf destinations in Shelter Island Heights. We've analyzed reviews and data from 2 local courses to help you find the perfect round.

2.2 Avg Rating
4,436 Avg Yards

Golf in Shelter Island Heights — 2026 Guide

Shelter Island Heights is home to 2 golf courses with an average player rating of 2.2 out of 5. Courses here average 4,436 yards in length, with the longest stretching 6,359 yards. The top-rated course is Shelter Island Country Club, rated 4.4 stars.

Browse our ranked list below to compare courses by rating, yardage, and hole count. Each listing links to detailed scorecards, photos, and player reviews to help you plan your next round.

Editor's Picks for Shelter Island Heights

🏆 Top Rated

Shelter Island Country Club

Rated 4.4 stars by players

The highest rated course in the region, offering a premium experience for golfers of all skill levels.

⛳ The Longest Drive

Gardiners Bay Country Club

6,359 yd from the back tees

A true test of distance. Bring your driver and get ready to cover some serious ground.

👥 Fan Favorite

Shelter Island Country Club

35 reviews

The most reviewed course in town. A popular choice among local players and visitors alike.

All Top Courses in Shelter Island Heights

#1

Shelter Island Country Club

Shelter Island Heights, New York

4.4 Rating
9 Holes
2,512 yd Length

The Shelter Island Country Club, known affectionately as "Goat Hill,” is a historic, nine-hole public golf course. The course was was established i...

View Details
#2

Gardiners Bay Country Club

Shelter Island Heights, New York

18 Holes
6,359 yd Length

Not far from Shelter Island Heights, Gardiners Bay Country Club offers terrific views and challenging play for golfers at every skill level. Well-g...

View Details

📍 Expand Your Search

Looking for more options? Find courses within driving distance of Shelter Island Heights.

Find Courses Within 25 Miles